FMV in the Tax and Audit File: Bonus Depreciation, the End of Aircraft 1031s, and Impairment
By David Fisher, ASA Senior Accredited Appraiser · · 4 min read
Valuation Matters, Part 6 of 7. 100% bonus depreciation is now permanent and aircraft no longer qualify for 1031 exchanges. Why both changes put more weight on a defensible fair market value.
Aircraft bonus depreciation is back at 100% and now permanent, while 1031 exchanges for aircraft are gone. Both changes raise the stakes on fair market value.
Aircraft rarely track their depreciation schedules. Book value falls on a straight line or an accelerated curve; market value moves with maintenance events, avionics, engine programs and the market cycle. For the CPAs, tax counsel and lessors, that divergence matters every time fair market value enters a return, a financial statement or an audit.
This article addresses valuation, not tax advice. Readers should confirm the treatment of any transaction with their tax advisor.
Bonus depreciation is back, and permanent
The One Big Beautiful Bill Act, signed July 4, 2025, permanently restored 100 percent first-year bonus depreciation for qualifying property, including new and pre-owned business aircraft acquired and placed in service after January 19, 2025. The scheduled phase-down under the 2017 tax law, which had cut the rate to 60 percent for 2024, is gone. The aircraft must still be used more than 50 percent for qualified business use in the year it is placed in service.
That makes valuation more important, not less. A first-year deduction equal to the full cost basis invites scrutiny, and a defensible file should show:
A supportable FMV at acquisition, reconciled to the purchase price and the asset’s basis.
Clear documentation of the placed-in-service date.
Evidence of qualifying business use.
How major upgrades or refurbishments were treated and valued.
With no expiration date looming, there is also less reason for buyers to rush a year-end closing on an aircraft with an unclean pre-buy.
1031 exchanges no longer apply to aircraft
This is still a common misconception, so it bears stating plainly. Since January 1, 2018, Section 1031 like-kind exchanges have been limited to real property. Aircraft, whether used for business or not, no longer qualify, and the 2025 legislation did not change that. When a depreciated aircraft is sold, the gain, including depreciation recapture, is generally recognized in the year of sale.
What replaced the exchange in practice is timing. Many owners pair the sale of one aircraft with the purchase of its replacement in the same tax year, using bonus depreciation on the new aircraft to offset recapture on the old. Both sides of that pairing rest on value: the sale price that drives the recapture, and the FMV that supports the new basis.
What actually drives FMV
Age and total time are starting points. The factors that most often explain a large gap between book value and FMV are:
Maintenance status. Aircraft just out of a major inspection or overhaul can be worth substantially more than the same model just before one.
Engine program enrollment. Coverage under programs such as MSP, TAP or JSSI reduces buyer risk and can account for differences of several hundred thousand dollars between otherwise similar aircraft. Transferability, coverage scope and accrued balances all matter.
Avionics and modernization. Glass cockpit conversions, ADS-B and WAAS/LPV compliance, and connectivity add value; unsupported legacy suites subtract it, sometimes by more than age does.
Documentation. Missing or reconstructed logbooks reduce value and weaken audit defensibility at the same time.
Use profile. High utilization accelerates maintenance; very low utilization raises corrosion and program concerns.
Market conditions. Supply, OEM production slots and the economy move values faster than any schedule.
Where FMV enters the accounting file
Situation
Why FMV matters
Acquisition and bonus depreciation
Supports basis and the first-year deduction
Section 179 elections
Supports the amount expensed and basis
Sale of an aircraft
Determines gain, loss and depreciation recapture
Major upgrades and refurbishments
Supports capitalization and the value added
Impairment testing
Market value below carrying value after damage, low utilization or a market downturn can trigger a write-down
Leases
Supports residual value assumptions and lease classification tests
Estates, gifts and ownership transfers
Establishes value as of the transfer date
Common errors that draw questions
Using a generic price guide value as FMV.
Ignoring recent upgrades or major maintenance events.
Misclassifying business versus personal use.
Failing to reconcile book value to FMV when a sale or impairment is in view.
Valuing as of the wrong date.
The bottom line
Permanent 100 percent bonus depreciation makes aircraft ownership more attractive, and the loss of the 1031 exchange makes each sale a taxable event. Both put more weight on a well-supported fair market value. An independent, USPAP-compliant appraisal with clear methodology and verified market data protects the client, and the advisor who signs the return. The final article in the series looks at how all of this comes together at the end of a loan: the exit.
David Fisher is the owner of Western Aviation in Houston and a Senior Accredited Appraiser with the American Society of Appraisers (ASA). He has more than 40 years of experience valuing business jets, turboprops and helicopters, and his reports are USPAP compliant.
Recovery in a forced aircraft sale depends on decisions made the day the loan closes: records, engine programs, configuration and knowing the next buyer.
We use essential cookies to make this site work. With your permission, we also use analytics cookies to understand how the site is used and marketing cookies to measure our advertising. Read our Cookie Policy.